Sim 2 (S9)
- Thread starter Donkey
- Start date
- Status
Foreman
Well-known member
- Messages
- 3,022
Overrated: Vince Carter. Don't get me wrong, he's good, but I'm not sure anyone else would've paid what user paid to get him in a trade.
Underrated: Jermaine O'Neal. Anyone would love to have O'Neal but he never really gets talked about because Panic doesn't hype him up due to trying to learn the piano to impress girls.
Underrated: Jermaine O'Neal. Anyone would love to have O'Neal but he never really gets talked about because Panic doesn't hype him up due to trying to learn the piano to impress girls.
Overrated - hate to say it but maybe AI? He’s had some good teams and never really went anywhere. He does look to have improved a bit tho this year
Underrated -Pau Gasol, everyone knows he’s good but the nets have been very good every year behind him as the guy and he looks like an elite player
Underrated -Pau Gasol, everyone knows he’s good but the nets have been very good every year behind him as the guy and he looks like an elite player
G9.
Pistons GM
- Messages
- 6,174
Who is the most overrated player in the league and why?
Kevin Garnett. No cap he is literally just Shawn Bradley with a bit more chances in the offense. But nobody would dare talk about trading multiple young specs / picks for Shawn.
Who is the most underrated player in the league and why?
Damon Stoudamire. Every season he has been featured he has been a 20/10 player. Defense is a bit sus but he is primo offense for an FBB point guard.
Kevin Garnett. No cap he is literally just Shawn Bradley with a bit more chances in the offense. But nobody would dare talk about trading multiple young specs / picks for Shawn.
Who is the most underrated player in the league and why?
Damon Stoudamire. Every season he has been featured he has been a 20/10 player. Defense is a bit sus but he is primo offense for an FBB point guard.
AiRuPtHeRe™
Well-known member
- Messages
- 4,375
Overrated: Amare Stoudemire
Sounds like Jon has turned down some really good players for Amare. He looks good ratings wise and he's young, but that was probably the best time to sell him.
Underrated: Hedo Turkoglu & Mike Dunleavy
Both guys are similar in terms of ratings and are guys who can put up 20 PPG if needed. Don't think the really get enough credit. Suns have 2 other guys you could add to this list (ZBO & Stoudamire)
Sounds like Jon has turned down some really good players for Amare. He looks good ratings wise and he's young, but that was probably the best time to sell him.
Underrated: Hedo Turkoglu & Mike Dunleavy
Both guys are similar in terms of ratings and are guys who can put up 20 PPG if needed. Don't think the really get enough credit. Suns have 2 other guys you could add to this list (ZBO & Stoudamire)
- Messages
- 9,272
Overrated:
Tough to not say Amare at this point I mean he’s shown basically nothing to this point but he’s been held as a premium blue chip asset. If his name wasn’t Amare Stoudemire he’s a guy you move 10/10 times without ever looking back if you’re getting an all star in return. He looks pretty much exactly like how Chris Anderson did and now he doesn’t even get minutes on a dogshit Nuggets team
Underrated:
Hmm, I mean I agree with most of that names above but I’ll throw another name into the mix so more guys can get their flowers but Damon Jones is a guy I’ve been after on the low for a couple years now and he’s finally getting a chance to show a bit of what he can do, and the funny part is he’s not even being run in settings that are conducive to his ultimate success. Think he’s a really great outside sniping, fastpaced, hyper efficient guard who can play decent defense and keep the TOs low. Wouldn’t be surprised if he wins a finals MVP one day.
Tough to not say Amare at this point I mean he’s shown basically nothing to this point but he’s been held as a premium blue chip asset. If his name wasn’t Amare Stoudemire he’s a guy you move 10/10 times without ever looking back if you’re getting an all star in return. He looks pretty much exactly like how Chris Anderson did and now he doesn’t even get minutes on a dogshit Nuggets team
Underrated:
Hmm, I mean I agree with most of that names above but I’ll throw another name into the mix so more guys can get their flowers but Damon Jones is a guy I’ve been after on the low for a couple years now and he’s finally getting a chance to show a bit of what he can do, and the funny part is he’s not even being run in settings that are conducive to his ultimate success. Think he’s a really great outside sniping, fastpaced, hyper efficient guard who can play decent defense and keep the TOs low. Wouldn’t be surprised if he wins a finals MVP one day.
Xxplayerxx23
Well-known member
- Messages
- 6,987
Amare- overrated. Jon passed on Lewis AI and rip for 2+ lol god. I’m sure his pot is still good tho but meh
underrated- Tough. Id say maybe Brandon thelack of offers for him is baffling to me. He’s a superstar. I get the age thing a little but not one offer of anything is crazy to me. Yes I used this as a trade block a little bit lol
underrated- Tough. Id say maybe Brandon thelack of offers for him is baffling to me. He’s a superstar. I get the age thing a little but not one offer of anything is crazy to me. Yes I used this as a trade block a little bit lol
BeatsHaveADream
Indiana Pacers GM
- Messages
- 4,478
Overrated - JJ Barea. Hes actually terrrible
Underrated - David Lee. People dont talk about him enough
Underrated - David Lee. People dont talk about him enough
mngopher35
Well-known member
- Messages
- 5,956
Overrated: I think Vince trade got a lot more than like Terry for example. It feels like he is valued much higher than some similar or even better players based on what that trade got in return.
underrated: Wally szczerbiak -never really talked about but when not injured he can put up a pretty efficient mid 20s ppg.
underrated: Wally szczerbiak -never really talked about but when not injured he can put up a pretty efficient mid 20s ppg.
Username
the best
- Messages
- 5,021
Overrated: Rashard Lewis - just been a lot of people on his dick recently and ion like that. Not many scorers on that team
Underrated: Damon Stoudemire - my mans won a ring with me, and with the Suns, he been a cannon his entire career shooting efficiently and passing hella dimes
Underrated: Damon Stoudemire - my mans won a ring with me, and with the Suns, he been a cannon his entire career shooting efficiently and passing hella dimes
Overrated: Kevin Garnett. Considered one of the best bigs in the league with A+ defense and his name, but he’s averaging 18/9/3. If his name wasn’t Kevin Garnett I think his value would be less
underrated: ostertag. At 30 years old, he does what you want a big to do. Defend and block with decent FT shooting while not taking lot of shots on offense
underrated: ostertag. At 30 years old, he does what you want a big to do. Defend and block with decent FT shooting while not taking lot of shots on offense
- Messages
- 24,703
Overrated: Insert any guy who only blocks shots here, especially those with lower defensive grades. So I'll say Jim McIlvaine here. People here fall in love with blocks here, and as a result McIlvaine has gotten so many big contracts. He should be a bench big, but he's consistently a starter.
Underrated: I didn't know who to pick here really so I looked around the league and I saw Ron Artest and he looks pretty sweet but nobody talks about him. He might have some volume if he was used as a 1 or a 2 option which could be a good considering his field goal percentage.
Underrated: I didn't know who to pick here really so I looked around the league and I saw Ron Artest and he looks pretty sweet but nobody talks about him. He might have some volume if he was used as a 1 or a 2 option which could be a good considering his field goal percentage.
Xxplayerxx23
Well-known member
- Messages
- 6,987
Lewis dominated with 2 other 20 point guys too so ima have to disagree with that one
Xxplayerxx23
Well-known member
- Messages
- 6,987
Im gonna have to disagree with both here heavily. ESP after that tc
hokeyrules
Well-known member
- Messages
- 2,906
Who is the most overrated player in the league and why?
Amare - looks better than he really is, should have been traded for more value previously
Who is the most underrated player in the league and why?
Mo Taylor - I think he will surprise some people in the next few years
Amare - looks better than he really is, should have been traded for more value previously
Who is the most underrated player in the league and why?
Mo Taylor - I think he will surprise some people in the next few years
- Messages
- 2,590
Overrated is far and away Amare. Jon has a habit of elevating his own guys to higher prices, but Amare doesn’t look like much at all. At least compared to offers that he’s been proposed in and turned down.
Underrated I would either go with #MyGuyWally or #MyFormerGuy Brandon. Wally is a lights out elite scorer and rebounder on great splits and he can play SG and SF at a high level. Brandon never gets the credit he deserves as one of the truly top tier talents that we’ve had in this iteration.
Underrated I would either go with #MyGuyWally or #MyFormerGuy Brandon. Wally is a lights out elite scorer and rebounder on great splits and he can play SG and SF at a high level. Brandon never gets the credit he deserves as one of the truly top tier talents that we’ve had in this iteration.
- Status