Preseason (S1)

[Donkey]

For $1.5M

Who are the 3 most valuable players on the file right now and why?

[Panic!]

Shaq - Can score
Grant Hill - Can defend
Garnett - Young

[monta8curry]

Jordan - best player
Shaq - young and dominant
GHill - young and a lockdown defender

[FortsonBass]

Shaq-best center, bird rights, young
Grant Hill-one of the best SF's, young, under contract for a while
Penny Hardaway-one of the best PG's, young, under contract for a while

[The Godfather]

I am going to answer MVP for season based on pre

Brandon..Cavs.. general of best record I'm the East
Mookie..Nuggs sets the pace as general of the best team in the league..elite defender very productive offensively
Shaq Orlando... unbelievable talent leads Magic to best in division

As far as MVP on File

KG so young so good perfect building block
Shaq Cloud knew Magic had the best player on file
MJ he is old but still the best overall player on file

[Foreman]

Shaq - Easily justifies to why the Magic were drafted first overall. Can trade him for nearly anything or compete at a high level with him.

MJ - Best player on the file, high name value. Can also trade him for nearly anything to a team ready to flip a switch, or to try and get a couple early rings.

Pippen - A+ defender, locked down for 3 years, and can place him against good players in the playoffs to cause problems for the other team.

[Username]

Shaq - young, arguably most dominant player on the file
Mj - best scorer, elite defender, efficient
Pippen - best defender in the league, capable of 20+ppg and also facilitates very well.

[NCツ]

Shaq - absurd numbers he can put up at center

MJ - GOAT

KG - good now and has hella pot

HM: Larry Johnson word to panic

[Xxplayerxx23]

MJ Best player on the file
Shaq young and as good as anyone
Hill- same as shaq. Crazy how good the magic are

[mngopher35]

1. Shaq - He is already right near the top and is only 23 years old, easiest choice imo

2. KG - A young superstar in the making, will be a top level player on the file eventually and for a long

3. Hill - Similar to KG, is already a little bit developed as well. I have him lower because my thought it KG's pot gets him above where Hill ends up. Crazy he was moved to the same team as Shaq.

[BeatsHaveADream]

Jordan- its mike
KG- that pot tho
David robinson - hes goat

[notail]

Shaq - top big man and young
KG - future all star if he uses his potential
Robinson - best big man in the league

[BradS4President]

Shaq - Double Double machine with solid handles. Going to run the league for years to come
MJ - Best all-around player. going to win a few rings to start here.
Grant Hill - If he develops his jump shot some...

[the_jon]

Shaq - Already insane at 23
David Robinson - Best player on the file currently imo
KG - Best rookie by a mile, should be a star

[GB]

Shaq beast
Kg young and potential to be great
Prob g hill young stud

soooo dumb magic have 2 of these guys lol thanks forty

[Scott]

Shaq - top player on the file when factoring in everything
MJ - best player in the file still and would make anyone a championship contender
David Robinson - basically who Shaq will become in the future

[Catdude]

Shaq - does this need explaining? He's 23 and is doing 25/12. He's gonna be dominant for a while
Jordan - He's the best player on the file right now, but he's also getting older. But he'll stay dominant for a few more years
Grant HIll - Another 23 year old who is already super talented. He can score, rebound, dish, and defend. He's the full package (as long as you're not running outside)

[hokeyrules]

Shaq - Young and amazing, so easily one of the top 3 players.
Jordan - Best player on file, although older than Shaq so if you want to win now its best to have him.
John Stockton - Want that PG who can pass better than everyone, you go stockton

[Donkey]

1. Shaquille O'Neal - He's still young and his ratings are already amazing. He's top 10 already at least in raw talent at 23.
2. David Robinson - In the midst of his prime but he is the 2nd or 3rd best player in the league right now.
3. Grant Hill - Again he's only 23, he has incredible ratings, if he had a shot he would be #1 on this list.

[Cloud]

Most trade value:

Shaq - 23 years old, good pot relative to how good he already is, one of the most dominant players already on both ends

Grant Hill - 24 years old, locked in for a long time on a good deal, A- inside and defense, plus rebounder, B+ handles great playmaker, strong jump shot, only thing he doesn’t do is shoot 3’s

Kevin Garnett - 19, best pot on the file, already a tremendous defender, going to be extremely well rounded

[LukaSZN]

1) Shaq - Age and potential to be the best player in the game.

2) Garnett (Second best pot on file behind king sheed.)

3) Robinson is getting you more wins in a vacuum than MJ

[cavsfan817]

Jordan is the best player, bar none.
Robinson is the best two way current player
Shaq is the best player when combining now and the future. Does everything and he’s so young.

[yrtb]

Shaq - 23 and already one of the best bigs in the league, in what's honestly a very big heavy file as far as star power goes

Michael Jordan - I think he's the best player in the file. Sure he's 33, but given the lack of dominant wing scorers, you can argue that he's the most valuable guy to have for winning a ring the next 3-5 years. It really depends on how fast he falls off

Grant Hill - A- inside/defense at 23 is absolutely insane. He's pretty much good at everything and will only improve from here

[AiRuPtHeRe™]

1. Shaquille O'Neal - Imagine if homie could make his FT's ... He'd be putting up 40.
2. David Robinson - A+ Defender. Can score 30 and lock you down.
3. Michael Jordan - Until he retires, he's still one of the best.

[Curry]

MJ: Goat
Shaq: 23 and already a STUD
Grant Hill: 24, great contract, and a fucking beast.