For: He has some of the best beefs going, and is a slave to those beefs.
Against: He's not a real man, he was unable to accept the consequences of his actions. Cheating was one thing, but running away from the problem was the worst part of it.
Against: They* are one of the most inactive GMs in terms of general day-to-day GM duties. Never sets DCs, sits on bad teams, and creates a bad situation in the event they quit.