Sim 4 + ASW (S4)

[Donkey]

For $3.0M, rank the top 5 players in this upcoming draft and give your reasoning for each player.

 

[G9.]

1 T Mac - just wouldn't pass up on him
2 Z Bo - hate big men but 18 with 2nd highest pot and should be fun offensive feature
3 JJ - could easily go 1. ray allen vibes
4 J Rich - another solid scorer who will be playable at 2/3
5 Sammy D - highest rebounder, 18, solid pot

 

[monta8curry]

1. TMac - all-around all-star by year two probably
2. J-Rich - vince carter-esque, good chance of a pot boost
3. Joe Johnson - him and JRich interchangeable depending on if you value shooting more
4. ZBo - 18 yr old big man with potential
5. Lamar Odom - controversial, but can do everything and play 3 positions legitimately

 

[Catdude]

1. T-Mac: I mean come on. B C+ C+ C+ C A. Best handles and 2nd best inside with fringe defense and A pot. He's gonna be a star
2. Joe Johnson: He's 18 and starting with C+/B offensive ratings. Dude is gonna score
3. Jason Richardson: B C+ C B- C at age 18?! Oh doctor! He's gonna do it all!
4. Lamar Odom: He's 19 starting at C+ C+ C C+ C A. Defense and rebounding are fringe. He's just super well rounded and could see him blowing up.
5. Corey Maggette: I was split here between him and Zbo but went with Corey. His handles worry me greatly, but he's 19, has the best inside in the draft and could make big strides with a few good TCs.

 

[Foreman]

1. T-Mac - solid base and seems like he'll have high volume right away.

2. Joe Johnson - Should have volume as well and should be able to grow into a serviceable defender.

3. Zach Randolph - should have a base to be able to score in the teens and will grow into a post presence with his high pot at 18.

4. Lamar Odom - Well rounded and would probably benefit from a move to SF.

5. Jason Richardson - only have him low due to his inside more than likely being all jumping. Should still get to a good 3&D type of player

 

[mattfaria12]

Tracy McGrady - Looks to be a good scorer already and has high Pot
Jo Johnson - Good scorer already too with high Pot
J rich - already a good scorer but potential looks lower than above
Corey Maggette - good inside scorer already plus he's one of my favourite players
Zach Randolph - High potential and already a good inside scorer with decent rebounding

 

[mngopher35]

TMac - Best player in the draft, should be real good
Joe Johnson - Looks like he will be a nice scorer
JRich - He also looks to be a nice scorer just with a little less pot
Zbo - Best big in the draft, decent rating at 18
Lamar Odom - Seems like a very well rounded player

 

[GB]

Tmac - looks like he’ll be awesome all around
Jason Richardson - has the base or a star and will have good athletics
Joe Johnson - diff type of scorer then the first 2 but should be a great one with great shooting
Zbo - would be higher being the best big and a teen, curious how he’ll develop defensively
Lamar Odom - if he develops well could be a very well rounded guy

 

[notail]

Tmac - has the base and potential to be great
Jason Richardson - young, athletic and with potential. boom or bust type tho
Joe Jognson - More polished scorer than Jrich but less athletic I would say. not great defensively so will need to improve there
Zbo - we know he's going to score. he has to be able to defend
Lamar Odum - Kukoc type of player

 

[Username]

1. Tmac - no brainer here, dude doesn’t have any low fringes, A pot, amazing base to
build on so I expect him to be the best player.
2. J-Rich - also a great base, 18 so 2 chances to boost. I don’t see him declining at all, he could develop into one of the best wings in the league.
3. ISO Joe - Looks to be an elite scorer off the rip, high C defense, 18 w A pot. Could be similar to Ray Allen I think, but younger with 2 chances to boost. He could he interchangeable at 2.
4. Zbo - we know his game, score and rebound. Hes 18 with A pot and a pretty good base. His defense is worry-some, but his scoring and rebounding may outweigh that negative part of his game, and he’s got pot and age on his side to develop that as well.
5. Sam Dalembert - could easily be one of the better D and rebounding bigs in the league with lots of pot. Probably the “safe” pick for anybody outside the top 3

 

[Panic!]

Haywood - teen High pot
Zbo - 18 high pot
Harrington - Teen high pot
Lamar Odom - Teen high pot
TMac - all around

 

[AiRuPtHeRe™]

1. Tracy McGrady - Solid all around base. Sucks that he's 20.
2. Jason Richardson - Could end up being better than McGrady if he boosts. Very similar build.
3. Joe Johnson - Could be a dope scorer. Another teen who could boost twice.
4. Zach Randolph - Another 18 year old. Should be pretty good offensively.
5. Corey Maggette - A little bit worse than Tmac and Jrich, but could boost once.

 

[NCツ]

1. T-Mac - easily should go 1
2. Joe Johnson - gonna be dope. Will be a VC / Ray Allen kinda guy
3. ZBO - 18 with second highest pot
4. Lamar Odem - great wings are hard to find, and he will likely be a very good SF
5. J Rich - 18 with a good base

 

[Donkey]

1. Tracy McGrady - For obvious reasons, there is a lack of wing talent in this league too.
2. Lamar Odom - Great ratings all around, super high ceiling.
3. Zach Randolph - Could end up being a big time scorer and defender.
4. Joe Johnson - Professional scorer
5. Jason Richardson - Really good base, but he's a dunker.

 

[Xxplayerxx23]

1- Tmac is the best player. Want him would trade a ton for him.
2-joe Johnson looks like a legit scorer right away
3- ZBo has potential to be an elite player
4-Odom looks to be a good all around player if he stays off the drugs
5- Richardson solid ratings could be a good player