Sim 2 (S6)

[Nate]

Where do you rank Brock Purdy among NFL starting quarterbacks? Tell us where you rank him and why.

$3 Mill

 

[Foreman]

32 because he destroyed a whole city's hopes and dreams.

Realistically, probably around 20

 

[Mzylinski]

10-20, probably around 13 or so. Need to see more before we judge completely

 

[notail]

I don't know him nor football that well so I will just place him at 15

 

[Cloud]

Mahomes
Burrow
Allen
Herbert
Lamar
Stroud
Rodgers
Dak
Goff
Cousins
Stafford
Tua
Kyler
Fields
Love
Hurts
Lawrence
Baker
Richardson
Watson
Wilson
Purdy
Geno
Daniel Jones
Carr
Howell
Bryce
Levis
Pickett
O’Connell / Jimmy G
Mac Jones / Zappe
Ridder


So I’d put him around 22ish

 

[Panic!]

He is number 2 next to Mahomes because he has a good arm.

 

[Xxplayerxx23]

He is number 2 next to Mahomes because he has a good arm.

…..

 

[yrtb]

I have him in the 12-15 range. He's good but not great. He's pretty good in the 49ers system, but I don't think he can elevate a team if he had less weapons.

 

[Panic!]

Put me back in group char

 

[Panic!]

Chat

 

[Just Swaggy]

I don't know that much about him, but from what I have seen of him which was only last game he played I would say he is a system player. He looks small for a QB which for some has never been a problem. Apparently he was the last pick in the draft so I like him for an underdog story, however that does not help his overall score compared to some guys like a Mahomes or a Lamar Jackson. No way he is up there with those guys. At the end of the day though it doesn't really matter. QB is probably the most important position in football, but it is also a team game so I mean if Prudy is a guy that fits your system and your beating guys that are top ranked QBs, but you have a better team shouldn't really matter. It's about the dub at the end of the day like always.

 

[Snypes89]

Top 15. Obviously a stud because of his draft position and you never expect to get that from the last draft pick. Definitely not top 10. 13-15 range.

 

[Snypes89]

Mahomes
Burrow
Allen
Herbert
Lamar
Stroud
Rodgers
Dak
Goff
Cousins
Stafford
Tua
Kyler
Fields
Love
Hurts
Lawrence
Baker
Richardson
Watson
Wilson
Purdy
Geno
Daniel Jones
Carr
Howell
Bryce
Levis
Pickett
O’Connell / Jimmy G
Mac Jones / Zappe
Ridder


So I’d put him around 22ish

Love is better then Fields

 

[Xxplayerxx23]

Put me back in group char

No

 

[Xxplayerxx23]

Top 15. He’s good he’s not great. Perfect sysyem
Amazing weapons all around him

 

[brooks]

18-22 range. He’s able to operate a system, but he mostly definitely does not enhance the abilities of those around him. How much would you be willing to pay him if he were expiring?

 

[Cloud]

Love is better then Fields

Nah I mean I don’t think that’s definitively true. Love had a great finish to the season and showed some good things and had more team success but he is in no way more talented that Justin. I put them right next to eachother I mean if you want to give Love a slight edge I’m fine with that but Justin is a better player than him imo and if he was even in a league average situation it wouldn’t even be a debate imo but we will see this year!

 

[GB]

15-20 range somewhere I guess. Hard to say since he’s had so much talent around him. But he did produce in that system so hard to call him a bottom 3rd qb.

 

[Swope]

Lmao I’m gonna say 150 bc some lists in here are just as unserious.

 

[Nate]

I mean, there’s only two quarterbacks left and he’s one of them. So that would make him top two!